Mailing List
Home
Forum Home
Softimage
Carrara
trueSpace
Dir3d-l
Maya - a powerful 3D animation and visual effects software
Macromedia Flash Development
Subjects
Cameras
scaleDown command
black out solved
Aircraft Tutorial
Mathematical XYZ ?
Its done This vs That
Its done first week
recommendations for screen video captures?
3DExplorer "Oddity "
New Director
ProTeam renewals
Fuel 's new websites (X post)
Blue peter create a make toy
targeting groups question
XPost: Shockwave 3D game ( sort of )
RES: RES: RES: Fish Modeling
Emitting particles from object intersection
Fuel 's new websites (X post)
Texturing
Big Break Contest Videos
New Plugins
Models and Texture on my updated site
Error Installing Patch tS6 6
Plasma?
Looking for Inspiration
Weird EMail Q
It 's done first week ?
Cherry not cranberry
New game
Camera Animation Problem
Particle plugins?
 
A render with problems

A render with problems

2003-12-13       - By Andrew Paules

 Back
Reply:     1     2     3     4     5     6     7  

Ahh the ever-present push of jobs. Ack. And I know exactly what you mean by
it's always good to get someone else to look at your images - it's amazing
the things you can miss after staring at an image for days.

Breakdown of things that catch my eye.

- the tesselation of the closest supporting arm - there's a kink on the
right end of it.

- the color of the shadows on the ground cast by the CG objects doesnt match
the color of the shadows cast by the people walking on the street. The fake
shadows should have more blue in them, and be slightly lighter because the
casting object is farther away. They should also have a big softer edges
than the shadows cast by the people.

- the blue poles dont seem to be "in" the environment that surrounds them -
adding in reflected light would help immensely, as well as perhaps a bit of
reflection. All of that could easily be done in your image editing
application of choice.

- the shadow falling on the pole to the right is far too dark - there would
be a ton of bounce light from the street hitting it from below to diffuse
that shadow.

- there arnt really any highlights on the pole where the sun should be
hitting it. If you look at the parts of the buildings that are being hit by
direct sunlight they're pretty washed out. Doing the same to the poles would
help a lot.

- there are no shadows falling on the poles from the trees that surround
them - again, this is would be quite easy to do in your image editing app.
Make a de-saturated version of the trees, overlay it on top of the pole, and
make a bump map of the poles to make the tree's shadow "wrap" around them.

- some of the "air cabins" dont look as if the sun is lighting them - if you
observe the cars parked on the street you'll see that the sun's light as a
de-saturating effect on the colors it hits. Applying a similar effect to the
cars in the air would be helpful.

- I'm not sure if the cabins are casting shadows on the ground - fI think
they are, but they're VERY stretched out - you might want to make some more
prominant shadows - it might not be realistic, but it will help to fool the
eye.

Think that's about it - cheers and good luck with your other projects,

|andrew|

__ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ __
Shop online for kids' toys by age group, price range, and toy category at
MSN Shopping. No waiting for a clerk to help you! http://shopping.msn.com